Seedly Communities vs Heartbeat Same toolkit. One payment.
Heartbeat is the closest thing to Seedly Communities in the rental market, feed, chat, courses, events, live rooms, payments. The difference is the deed. Their unlimited-members tier is $849 a month. Ours is $399 once.
Seedly Communities
$399
one time
You own itThe full source code, yours forever.
Heartbeat
$1,788
/ year
You rent itBuild is $49 a month, capped at 350 members with a 5% fee. Unlimited members costs $849 a month.
The honest version
Feature parity, business-model gap.
Heartbeat deserves the honest credit first. It is a well-scoped product with custom domains on every plan, real monetization, and built-in automations, the closest feature-for-feature rival Seedly Communities has.
The structure is the story. Member caps per tier, 350 on Build and 5,000 on Grow, with unlimited only at $849 a month. Revenue fees of 5%, 2.5%, or 1.25% stacking on Stripe by tier. A branded app locked at the top tier, while the app that exists rates around 3.5 stars, with documented reports of white screens, phantom notification dots, and posts that appear published but never publish. Export means filing a support ticket.
When the feature lists match this closely, the comparison collapses to the business model. Rent the toolkit forever, with caps and fees, or buy the toolkit once for $399.
Side by side
Seedly Communities vs Heartbeat, row by row
Seedly Communities
Heartbeat
Price
Member caps
Transaction fees
Own the software
Feed, chat, courses, events, live
Custom domain
Branded mobile app
Mobile experience today
Managed hosting + uptime
Instant start
Automations
Data export
Competitor pricing, fees, and review scores verified July 2026 from vendor pricing pages and cited third-party sources. Plans change often, so confirm current details on each vendor's site. Seedly Communities is a one-time license plus your own hosting on accounts you control.
The math that matters
Unlimited members, two prices.
Heartbeat's Grow plan is $149 a month, $8,940 over five years, and it caps you at 5,000 members. Build is $49 a month, $2,940 over five years, capped at 350 members with a 5% revenue fee. Unlimited members their way is $849 a month, $50,940 over five years. Unlimited members our way is $399, once. That is the starkest per-member math in the category.
The fees stack too. At $30,000 a year in member revenue on Grow, the 2.5% cut is about $750 a year on top of rent, before Stripe's own fees.
Seedly Communities has no caps anywhere in the code, no revenue fee, and payments run through your own Stripe. Your ongoing cost is your own Convex and Vercel hosting. Bought together with Seedly CRM in one checkout, it is $150.
The whole point
Growth should not be an invoice.
The caps are the quiet upgrade engine. Member 351 on Build is not a milestone, it is an invoice. On software you own, growth costs you nothing extra, which is the whole reason to own a toolkit you already like.
And the rent does not buy reliability. The 3.5-star app reports, white screens and posts that never publish, come from paying customers. Our mobile story is honest and modest, responsive web plus Capacitor shells you configure, but nothing about your community waits on a landlord's bug queue.
Getting out
Getting out of Heartbeat, honestly.
Heartbeat's export runs through support tickets, posts, comments, docs, and members per their help docs. Request everything before you cancel, while the account still answers.
Then the standard manual move. Invite members through Seedly's invite links and email invites, re-seed your cornerstone content, and re-anchor subscriptions on your own Stripe with fresh opt-ins. No importer exists on our side.
Straight talk
When Heartbeat is the right call
Heartbeat gives you managed hosting, built-in automations, and a real if rough dedicated mobile app today, with zero deploy work. If you will never touch a deploy dashboard, rent theirs.
If you can spend one setup weekend, own ours.
Andrew
Founder, Seedly Communities
Questions, answered
Seedly Communities vs Heartbeat, the common questions
Feature for feature, what is actually different?
Less than you would think on the toolkit, feed, chat, courses, events, live, payments, both sides have them. The differences are the deed, the caps, and the fees. Heartbeat rents you the toolkit with member caps and a revenue cut. Seedly sells you the source once, with unlimited members and 0% fees.
Does Seedly have built-in automations like Heartbeat?
No, and Heartbeat wins that row. Seedly gives you outbound webhooks and a REST API, 8 endpoints across 6 resources, to wire into the automation tools you already use, but there is no built-in automation builder.
What happens at member 351?
On Seedly, nothing, there are no member caps anywhere in the code. On Heartbeat's Build plan, member 351 is the moment you upgrade tiers, which is how caps are designed to work.
What about the mobile app?
Seedly ships responsive web plus Capacitor iOS and Android shells you configure and submit yourself, there is no managed native app service. Heartbeat has a dedicated app today, currently rated about 3.5 stars with documented bugs. Both halves of that sentence are true, so weigh them honestly.
What do I need to run it?
Your own Convex, Vercel, and Stripe accounts plus a guided deploy weekend. It is source you own, deployed on infrastructure you control, with no tier ladder waiting as you grow.
Stop renting. Own the thing your community runs on.
Buy the source once. Run it yourself. It is yours for good.
One payment. Unlimited members. 0% platform fees.
- Full platform source code
- Unlimited members, no caps or seat fees
- 0% transaction fees, your own Stripe
- Feed, chat, classroom, events, live video
- Gamification with points, levels, and streaks
- White-label design tokens + your domain
- Commercial license included
Secure checkout via Stripe. Your license key is emailed instantly.
Compare Seedly Communities with others